Local Pizza For Columbus & Fall River, WI
Day One Pizza offers delicious pizza, sandwiches, & more. Online ordering for pickup and delivery to Columbus & Fall River, Wisconsin
Proudly serving the Columbus & Fall River area for over🎉🥳✨🍕25years!
Introducing Our New Items
Check out the latest crave-worthy additions to the Day One Pizza menu — made fresh daily with premium ingredients and bold local flavor.
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
A delicious combination of creamy ranch sauce, extra chicken, shredded mozzarella, a touch of cheddar cheese, & crispy bacon
12 Inch Cheese Sticks
Freshly baked dough brushed with butter and garlicssimo, topped with shredded mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
14 Inch Cheese Sticks
Freshly baked dough brushed with butter and garlicssimo, topped with shredded mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
Local Specialty Pizzas
Fresh ingredients, hand-tossed dough, and our signature sauce. Crafted to perfection for over 25 years.
Taco Grande
Taco bean sauce, beef, and cheddar; topped with lettuce, taco chips, cheddar, diced tomatoes, yellow onions, and black olives. (Taco sauce packets and sour cream cups extra).
Mac & Cheese Pizza
Amazing 6-cheese mac & cheese, cut from whole bricks of cheese, topped with our mozzarella blend, and baked to perfection on our pizza crust. (A kid favorite that adults will love!).
Meat Works
A savory, delicious meat-lover's dream loaded with classic pepperoni, mild sausage, hearty beef, premium Canadian bacon, and crispy bacon. Guaranteed to satisfy your biggest cravings!
Baked Potato
A unique, addictive twist on a classic! Rich creamy alfredo sauce, our signature mozzarella cheese blend, melted cheddar, crispy bacon, and golden potato fries baked to perfection.
BBQ Chicken
A sweet and smoky BBQ sauce base loaded with tender grilled chicken, crisp yellow onions, crispy bacon, and our signature mozzarella cheese blend topped with melted cheddar.
Creamy Chicken Alfredo
A rich and creamy alfredo sauce base generously topped with extra diced grilled chicken, fresh juicy tomatoes, sliced mushrooms, and our signature melted mozzarella cheese blend.
Veggie Works
A vibrant, colorful vegetarian delight piled high with fresh sliced mushrooms, crisp yellow onions, crunchy green peppers, black olives, and fresh juicy diced tomatoes.
Feta One
A Mediterranean-inspired masterpiece featuring creamy garlic white sauce, fresh cut spinach, zesty red onions, fresh diced tomatoes, our mozzarella cheese blend, and crumbled feta.
Dietary Notice: If you have food allergies please notify a manager. Cross-contact with wheat flour (gluten) is possible as all pizzas are topped in a common kitchen.
Gift Certificates: Gift certificates are not redeemable online yet. Phone or in-store orders only for now.
Why we stand out?
Fresh, Local Ingredients
We source the freshest ingredients daily, ensuring every bite is filled with flavor.
Fast, Hot Delivery
Your pizza arrives hot and fresh, delivered quickly right to your door.
Signature Crust Styles
Available in our legendary Cracker Thin & Crispy, Regular Hand-Tossed, or Thick Pan Style crusts—crafted to perfection for over 25 years.
Crafted with Care
Family recipes and a deep passion for great food are at the heart of everything we do.
What Our Neighbors Are Saying
"The absolute best pizza in the Columbus area! The regular hand-tossed crust is perfect, and they never skimp on the toppings. Our family movie nights always include Day One."
"Celebrating over 25 years for a reason! The staff is always incredibly friendly, the pizza arrives hot, and that Taco Grande pizza is legendary. Highly recommend!"
"Consistently great food and fast service. The Garlic Breadsticks are a must-order every single time. A true staple of the Fall River and Columbus community."
"Love this place. Great crust options, amazing specialty pies (the Meat Works is incredible), and you can tell they care about their customers. Here's to another 25+ years!"
"We've always done carryout here and have never had a bad pizza. The sauce is what I love most, it's perfectly seasoned. Always hot and fresh!"
"Best pizza in Columbus. The Mac & Cheese pizza is a game changer. My kids won't eat anything else! The service is always friendly and the pizza is always fresh."
